So when I ran out last month I bought a bottle from Kohls and although the scent is the same it only lasts for about 2 hours vs. the one from Budapest lasted me all day, even the next morning I could smell traces of it sometimes. 
I bought this when I was looking for a soft and feminine scent for me. January 11, 2006 at 1:37pm Reply, Ayala: The Narcisso Rodriguez line is indeed very confusing. I thought that I would at least find Un Jardin sur le Nil intriguing or memorable. when me and my family first started using it, it was light, non over powering didn't react with other products and lightly settled on the skin. The fact is, she already had her unique fragrance ready to go. Now I'm looking for something else. It is brand new but if you have a chance to sample it before it really hits the market you should try it. Subsequently, the affinity of the chypre accord with the voluptuous fruity and floral notes has been discovered, resulting in the orchestrations that fused various flowers, peach (Guerlain Mitsouko, Rochas Femme), plum (Guerlain Parure, Shiseido Fminit Du Bois), as well as exotic fruit (Jean Patou Colony) with the classical chypre accords. Lovely by Sarah Jessica Parker for Women, Eau de Parfum, 3.4-Ounce Spray Bottle, Acqua di Gio Absolu by Giorgio Armani Review, Bleu de Chanel Parfum vs. Acqua di Gio Profumo, Index of all of our Fragrance Reviews for Men and Women. This is not the first time I have noticed that EU made fragrances are higher quality even though they are the same brand and everything. Some musks can be very expensive and amberlyn in NR is a very expensive ingredient as well. The inexpensive price, is one of the main strengths of this scent, along with its aroma, and versatility. 
In fact, they fade off into the ether fairly quickly. She agreed that it doesnt smell like chypre. wrongly, because you are a pretty smell, which I can not classify completely.a quiet smell you are not, at least for my conditions.the association with tingling rose champagne, I find quite appropriate.you have such an invigorating, lively.somehow you are also sexy, but quite in the youth-free area. How do you feel about both scents? 
Moreover, I am very glad that you brought up the question of classification, because I was hoping for a little bit of a discussion on this issue. I bought a bottle of lovely this morning and I cannot stop smelling myself. It tends to last around 6-7 hours on the skin, which is great for how light it is. Well, shed already been mixing her signature scent through a combination of three aromas. March 13, 2007 at 11:49am Reply. And it has a strange consistency of a personal lubricant, if you will excuse me for the vulgarity, which kind of makes me steer away from wanting to apply it. I was really disappointed by smelling both perfumes:Narciso and Lovely. January 11, 2006 at 2:42pm Reply, BoisdeJasmin: Ayala, great descriptions. January 11, 2006 at 2:11pm Reply. I think I expected a little more from SJP's first perfume, hence the reason why I was so disappointed. . The chypric ambery facet of its composition is slightly reminiscent of Miss Dior Cherie, which was created by Christine Nagel, although in Narciso Rodriguez, the woody-musky ornamentation renders the effect to be more sophisticated and refined. Well, I find Lovely to be easier to wear, and since the skin scents are the kind of fragrances I would need to be in a mellow mood for, I would probably choose Lovely January 11, 2006 at 2:27pm Reply, BoisdeJasmin: Christine, thank you. I like both quite a bit, and I would have difficulty choosing. I am told that the parfum is softer, but I have not tried it yet. I purchased it from Douglas (european equivalent of Sephora) at the Mall. Id call it a light moderate perfume. Narciso Rodriguez for Her (2003) was created by Christine Nagel and Francis Kurkdjian for the fashion designer famous for his elegant and graceful silhouettes. March 12, 2007 at 11:53pm Reply, BoisdeJasmin: Leoness, fragrance impressions are very subjective, and often one fragrance that smells awful on one person will smell glorious on another. Please see other reviews of musk dominated perfumes. Since I have learned how much else is out there, has been pushed back into the 'it's OK, but nothing fantastic' category for me. Its peachy and rosy indeed. It has a very immediate effect. I even came up in a rash after using it. Thanks a lot for the detailed reviews of both Lovely and Narcisso Rodriguez. Do I like Lovely by SJP? I discovered this often with Coco Mlle. January 11, 2006 at 2:16pm Reply, BoisdeJasmin: M, yes, Lovely is much softer and gentler. Its not really a winter sort of scent, but it wouldnt be bad, in that weather. January 11, 2006 at 2:21pm Reply, BoisdeJasmin: Madelyn, thank you! I'm still not sure about my feelings for this one. January 11, 2006 at 8:34pm Reply, BoisdeJasmin: Michelle, labdanum often is used in amber accords, and since it was a part of the original Coty Chypre, many sources would list it as an important ingredient for a classic chypre accord. The EDP also features rose and peach, being more floral, with the accent on pink roses, than the original EDT, although it is admittedly less interesting. Everfumed participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we get paid commissions on purchases made through our links to retailer sites. Sometimes you get what you pay for. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. How? Lovely features notes of mandarin, bergamot, rosewood, lavender, apple martini, patchouli, paper whites, orchid, cedar, white amber, musk and woods. Further details in the disclaimer. I have used Lovely since it first came out. The only musks wich i find sensual are MUSC RAVAGEUR (cinnamon at first disturbs me,then,after an hour,musc ravageur is absolutely wonderful of sensuality,almost sexual to me)and serge Lutens MKK in a much more animalistic way. Yet, personally I would never had called any of these fragrances chypres if I did not see the classification beforehand, but comparing them side by side, I begin to see the similarity of their base accords and why they might be classified together. Contact At any rate, I find this curious and puzzling as well, hence my interest in raising the topic in the first place to see what opinions others have on this. Too brass/brash and it doesnt settle down. I am sorry,but i dont think so. They are miles away from the typical chypre. Id still probably go with any fragrance, that would be more suitable, however. At first, you think that she is attractive and then you begin to be tired of her. I have been just thinking about these two this morning, and was planning to try them again Perfect timing! Especially when these scents focus on musk. This means if you click a link and make a qualified purchase through Amazon, I earn a commission based on that sale. The right to repair movement in Australia is calling for companies to make it easier for their products to be repaired. Gift options for beauty junkies are endless, but that can make finding the right present difficult. In general, I do not like oil based perfumes. Worn this perfume since it came out. To me it screams of Summer Love . We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. I strongly feel that they are classified as such because of pure marketing purposes as people that are attracted to chypres are likely to be attracted to musky skin scents as well. Michael Edwards classifies Narciso Rodriguez and Pure Turquoise in Mossy Woods category that contains Ma Griffe (to give a point of reference). I purchased. Dont waste your money. I have to admit that the texture did not appeal to me at all for the same reason you mentioned. It is subtle enough for the office, can go casual, and generally serve as a no-brainer for daily wear. Here are some electronics and appliance manufacturers who are starting to listen and make it more feasible for consumers to repair, rather than replace, their items. It is light yet seems to be present and lasts throughout the day. The fruity note of apple sweetens the composition without lending a cloying touch. For a celebrity fragrance, this one is of good quality, and at a cheap price. January 12, 2006 at 4:30pm Reply, BoisdeJasmin: Seriously! The finished product is a truly magical scent now well take a deep dive into what makes this scent so special. January 11, 2006 at 4:44am Reply. Lacking the immediate impact of Narciso Rodriguez, it may be less unusual, but at the same time an easier fragrance to wear. I find the eau de toilette juice more appealing to me over the Eau de Parfum. I would heartily recommend it for warm weather use. I adore them, for me they are very very sensual yet refined. People also like to use this as a cheaper alternative to fragrances like Narciso Rodriguez, so, while it lacks originality and can be a great substitute for more expensive designer scents. January 11, 2006 at 2:23pm Reply, BoisdeJasmin: Cait, I find the changes in what is classified as chypre both fascinating and confusing. Narciso Rodriguez for Her and Sarah Jessica Parker Lovely are two examples of the classification that would consider them as floral oriental compositions with chypre accords and they are often compared. BoisdeJasmin: Julien, I suppose that you prefer the balmier, more chocolatey richness of musk in Musc Ravageur. However it is now so diluted or they have changed something and the scent now doesnt last 5 mins I would not buy again. It is not an overly complex fragrance, and indeed it is not as rich and interesting as Narciso Rodriguez, however it is subtle and refined, like a comfortable silk slip. You can find a less expensive version at stores like Target. Synthetic musks vary a bit, from metallic freshness to fruity sweetness to balmy warmth. I just can't bear it. Along side of this, I get some mandarin orange, a bit of apple, and orchid. I cant wear NR, it gives me a raging headache. Longevity is pretty good, but not great. Sarah Jessica Parker Lovely is one of my favourite perfumes. The mandarin and apple notes, arent all that strong, within this composition. There also exist versions called Musk for Her and Musk Oil, which are blends of musks, lacking the floral notes of the original. Ralph Lauren Pure Turquoise, Lulu Guiness Cast a Spell, Dior Miss Dior Cherie, Chanel Chance, Coco Mademoiselle EDT are the examples of the fragrances released in the past couple of years and classified as posssessing chypre accords. I like the addition of amber and vanilla to NR and Lovely. It is a fine fragrance, and I wore it for about a year when it was first released. January 11, 2006 at 2:26pm Reply, BoisdeJasmin: C, I find Lovely more subtle and softer, with NR having more of a presence. Weak as tea. Perhaps, it is indeed a smell of some Russian shampoo? But subtle. The musk is offensive and the entire composition is headache/allergy inducing.
I'm a writer, journalist and professionally trained perfumer. Like Narciso Rodriguez for Her, Lovely (2005) with its gossamer layers is supported by a base of luscious musks and woody amber. I loved the juxtaposition of a fruity floral superimposed on a soft amber- vanilla richness. Ltd. All Rights Reserved. Bathed in the voluptuous musky richness, the composition has a decadent feel of a silk dress, and even the slight sharpness that marks the EDT, perfectly conjures the sensation of rubbing raw silk against the cheek. While Narciso Rodriguez intersperses its musky layers with the woody richness and caramelized sweetness that reveals a vanilla bean pod one moment and a handful of raw sugar crystals the next, Lovely leaves a creamy trail, soft and delicate. Love to you Victoria and reader friends allover. The right to repair: which brands are making it easier for you to fix their products? I only use about 2-3 sprays and that is enough for the entire day. The group has been out of fashion for a long time and I wonder if the majority of consumers (especially those Lovely is targetting) might be attracted to the classical chypre. The Lovely bottle is gorgeous Simple, but very pretty! But it surely differs from other musk scents which I often find too clean smelling. When Sarah Jessica Parker decided to put a two-decade-long dream of creating her own fragrance into action, she didnt start with a blank slate. I loved your eloquent review of Narcisco Rodriguez ! As it dries down further, the scent really settles down, on my skin. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Welcome to Bois de Jasmin! My favourite musks are FM Musc Ravageur, Armani Emporio White for Her (white musk) and SL Bois et Musc. Like you, I love animalic chypres, but I noticed that hedione-patchouli combination also appeals to me very much. Fast forward to 2019 and I decided to re-purchase another bottle and give it another chance but unfortunately, I ended up with the same result. Our editorial content is not influenced by any commissions we receive. Lovely isnt too powerful of a scent. It was also one of those fragrances where you have to push your nose onto your wrist in order to smell the scent. There are three concentrations of Narciso Rodriguez for Her: the EDT packaged in black bottle, the EDP packaged in pink and the parfum in a rectangular clear vial with a dropper. To help keep the site running, I utilize affiliate links as a source of revenue. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. I have never worn the perfume oil together with it, but I tried once and found it very pleasant and soft. ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. I bought a bottle of Lovely, cause I looooooove SJP! On these pages I explore the world of senses through art, literature, and history. Indeed, it does speak of some change in what chypre means, and I would be curious to explore it further. I wish they would make up a new category for these fragrances instead of trying to fit them clumsily into the existing families. I know that he works with a team of perfumers before making a decision. Whenever I wear it people say" Oh! Staying at home doesnt have to be a drag, even if youre isolating. January 11, 2006 at 2:23pm Reply, michelle: I read somewhere that the defining notes for a chypre are: bergamot, oakmoss, musk and amber. It doesn't cost you any more money and it helps keep the site running. This isnt a romantic wear or even a nightlife fragrance. January 13, 2006 at 3:58pm Reply, malini: I was recommended Lovely at Nordstroms when I was looking for a chypre fragrance. Both Narciso Rodriguez for Her and Lovely are available from Nordstrom, Saks 5th Avenue, as well as a number of other retailers and online discounters. January 13, 2006 at 4:23pm Reply, Tania: It makes you think theyve classified these things chypres because the oriental category was getting so crowded that they wanted to move some out. cent to something I don't like, and it does not have the staying power it used to. These scents sound pleasant. I also request it for birthdays and Christmas. I know what you mean about the EDT softening significantly, more so than could be expected.
Whats funny, though, is that for all the attention centered on Lovely and the Herms scent, I found them both to be first and foremost dull. I start to get smoother woods, more lavender, less intensity in the musk, and the orchid still sitting pretty within it all. - Victoria, Nancy Chan in 5 Perfume Masterpieces for Summer: Definitely not discontinued. Copyright 2022 Everfumed | Fragrance Notes, Nathalie Feisthauer Interview: Sense of Independence, Michael Kors Sexy Blossom Eau de Parfum Spray Review: Classic & Versatile, 8 Best YSL Colognes For Sophisticated Men, 12 Best Philosophy Perfumes: Long-lasting & Perfect For Every Event, 21 Best Tuberose Fragrances: Fresh, Beautiful & Exotic. The rest being optional. I love the perfume oil. Someone who tried the real musk tincture said that Musc Ravageur did a great job in capturing it. Sarah Jessica Parker oversaw the creative direction of the fragrance, but she couldnt do it alone. Chypres are among my favorites. It is now overpowering and the smell is not nice at all. It's not over powering. Another related issue could be that they merely have a chypre accord (which does not make them chypre per se). Chypre should contain floral, woody and mossy notes (there seems to be a consensus here), and bergamot and oakmoss are important, as the citrus-mossy interplay is what makes a classical chypre accord. January 12, 2006 at 10:54am Reply, BoisdeJasmin: I used to wear it at one point, but I got tired of it quickly. Ive been using that as my reference point but am curious to hear if there are other definitions. According to the Sex and the City star, she knew what she wanted even before her first meeting with her perfumer. January 11, 2006 at 1:23pm Reply, marchlion: What Ayala said. How does it perform? The crisp sweetness embellished with citrus fruitiness gives way to the floral heart, dominated by orange blossom. Do you know about the process for official classification? It almost becomes warm and skin-like. I imagine that you could over spray this, but the sillage isnt going to take over a room, with normal application. Ive sampled both Narciso Rodriquez for Her and Lovely, and I like them both, although I prefer the NR EDT over the EDP (and over the Lovely for that matter). Yes, lavender and orchid are strong too, but musk and patchouli are notes which can turn some folks off from a fragrance. Its best suited to day-time wear in the summer. i dnt normally enjoy flowery smelling perfume but when i wear it I'm surprised how much I like it!
Cannot stand those perfumes any longer. I wouldnt dare wear this scent to work or the university, but find it a classy scent to wear to symphony concerts and on special evenings out. I guess Im an animalic-chypre type, although Diorella really rocks my boat as well. It's not an amazing perfume, but does it need to be? Enjoy yours too! It seems to hit the 6-7 range for me, on a consistent basis, during testing. January 11, 2006 at 9:27pm Reply, Karin: I love what you said about Coco Mad. I am glad to hear that you are enjoying this fragrance. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. This is far from a criticism, however, as For Her gives that same great aroma but at a fraction of the price. Don't subscribe This website uses cookies to improve your experience. What is your favorite musky scent? were I kept my old one and it smells light and flowery on all of our skin types. BoisdeJasmin: C, it sounds like you tried the EDT. Lovely has a spicy top accord, touched by a soft herbaceous verdancy and a muted glitter of citrus. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. However, many fragrance companies have their own tools in classifying as well. You will have people asking what are you wearing all the time! Laurent Le Guernec and Clement Gavarry of IFF worked closely with the actress Sarah Jessica Parker to create her first fragrance. Notify me of replies to my comments via e-mail. I am sure that as with food and all of the commercial arts, France has a classification process. Of course, there are many chypres without labdanum, but with other types of notes that give a warm feeling that characterizes chypre accords. Is it even worth a purchase? We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Once I get past that, it's good. I know you all try your best, but please do try a little harder to keep an open mind. than I am/or feel Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Your source for reviews on the top fragrances. I tried this on at Chemist Warehouse and forgot about it. I loved the bottle, but not the scent. 5 minutes after testing it, though, I could only vaguely even remember it, and never went back to try it again. I found Pure Turquoise to pretty much exemplify everything I hate in a modern perfume. It is SO diluted the smell didnt even stay on the body for more then 20mins and it suppose to be perfume. This is a public forum presenting user opinions on selected products and businesses, and as such the views expressed do not reflect the opinion of ProductReview.com.au. I think I like it. The final dry down is a floral/musky scent with a base of cedar and other non-distinct woody notes. I can smell hints of orange blossom. Its hard to find now but i usually purchase from Chemist Warehouse at a very reasonable price. In fact, I have the EDT and to supplement amall perfume oil. This means that if you click on an Amazon affiliate link on my pages, I receive a commission based on that qualified purchase. So disappointing!! Whether its a skincare essential, a cult makeup product, or the latest hair styling tool, youll find something for all kinds of beauty lovers in our gift guide. My sis used to wear it and I had to beg her to stop. This is the original and best seller from the Sarah Jessica Parker line and it does a good job at representing the brand. In this particular instance, I'd go for the quality of For Her over the wallet friendly Lovely. In the past, whenever I would smell NR, I would feel it in my throat a little as well, however it has not been happening after the first couple of times.
*. I ran out at some point and I need to repurchase. The very definition of the chypre seems to be changing, with the emphasis made on the transparent and fruity notes combined with the chypre facets, and many fragrances classified as chypre these days do not even seem to be related to the classical chypre accords. Best Mens Colognes started back in 2013, as a way to share my learning experiences with different fragrances, as I dove head first into the hobby. Check! In summer heat I love Guerlain Aqua Allegoria Pamplelune, and Hermes Un Jardin Sur Le Nil. I dont know why, it might smell like some shampoo or conditioner she used to useAnyway, for that reason I find Lovely a comforting scent January 11, 2006 at 10:11am Reply, Cait: Hello, I use Narciso Rodriguez, both the EDT and the EDP (which Im wearing today). To achieve her dream, she employed the help of the Lancaster creative perfume house one of the most prominent houses for helping designers and celebrities translate their fragrance ambitions into reality. I do not mind it, however I can see that if you wanted the fragrance to preserve the initial sparkly effect, it may not be a good thing. The JM July 30, 2022 at 4:47pm, Trudy in 5 Perfume Masterpieces for Summer: I enjoyed this post and all the comments so much. julien: I am not fond of musky scents. It was back on the Chanel website about 2 weeks ago, then sold out very quickly. Not much different than musks that I have tried in headshop stores I dare say, but smells less cheap more subtle. I disagree, however, with any classification of those scents as chypre, as well as Pure Turqoise. I was very happy to discover i could still wear this. January 11, 2006 at 11:15pm Reply, linda: Coco Mlle is the number one headache inducing perfume for me. Think of it as a generalist rather than a specialist perfume. January 12, 2006 at 5:57pm Reply, Deloris: I fell in love with Pure Turquoise by Ralph Lauren. While Narciso Rodriguez is more assertive about its sensuality, Lovely hints at it gently. scents are so far afield from what was chypre, its hard to think of them that way. January 11, 2006 at 2:44pm Reply, Marina: V, I also find Lovely easier to wear. The performance is solid and it can be an easy daily wear for many women (and already is). Which one do you prefer? ida: I must say that all the 15 year old slutty girls with fake hair, fake nails and too tight jeans wear Coco Mlle and Chance. I used to have many perfumes but sadly i developed a fragrance allergy. And what about you,my dear? Both are refreshing and seem to last July 30, 2022 at 4:17pm, Frederic Malle LEau dHiver and Paul & Joe Blanc : Perfume Reviews, 7 Discoveries from 12 Years of Bois de Jasmin, Danilo Kis The Encyclopedia of the Dead, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQSOMLQ0jv8. It was a beautiful long lasting scent. Sitemap. July 30, 2022 at 5:06pm, Trudy in 5 Perfume Masterpieces for Summer: Ive always wanted to try the Hermes Un Jardin Sur Le Nil. One needs to be suprecareful and resist the urge to reapply as to not end up with a headache. Sorry but has this product change? TOP COLOGNE GIFT SETS FOR THE HOLIDAY SEASON! I will search it out next time Im in Nordstrom. Purchased in January 2020 at Chemist Warehouse Physical Store for $30. I was wearing Joy. Michael Edwardss became the prime person in classifying, and he works with a team of perfumers and advisors in trying to get these classifications correctly. But for the first couple of hours, all I get is "feminine hygiene product" floral. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. I loved the original Lovely scent I used to get at perfume counters of stores like Elder Beerman & Macy's, but now it is much cheaper and is not carried by the department stores anymore. I cannot wear that at all. My boyfriend gave it to me for valentines day. There is something very alluring about musk, as it is simple and complex at once, clean and at the same time clean. The EDP notes include pink chypre, pink floral, voluptuous woods, soft amber, sheer chypre, flower honey, tactile woods, amber light. When should it be worn? These cookies do not store any personal information. The main similarity between them is in their luxurious musk accords touched with the ambery warmth that makes these compositions melt beautifully on the skin, and while the fragrances are by no means identical, they create a similar effect of warm, sensual softness. This fragrance is lovely. I don't care about the packaging, but the manufacturing or ingredients must be cheaper as well. Me and my daughter has been using LOVELY for nearly 7yrs but our last purchased 15/1/18 was a disappointment. What does it smell like? The EDP is way too sweet and floral in my opinion which is kind of dissapointing, but its also quite nice. Seems like the most logical explanation. This fragrance is well rounded enough that it would suit a younger lady just as well as one more mature. January 15, 2006 at 2:09pm Reply, Leoness: I doubt any of you will get a chance to read this (afterall, the review was over a year ago), but I have to say that Coco Mademoiselle is not as bad as everyone has made it out to be.